Querétaro drafted 173 rulings aided by its own generative AI; Mexico's case law on judicial AI comes from a single collegiate court and the Supreme Court has issued no criterion
Translated from the Spanish original.
On September 29, 2026, the Poder Judicial de Querétaro (Querétaro state judiciary) reported 173 rulings drafted with the support of artificial intelligence, 70 in family matters and 103 in civil matters, out of more than 20,000 issued during the year; it uses an institutional language model on its own servers, under guidelines from its Consejo de la Judicatura (Judicial Council), and issued the first such ruling in April. In the same period, filings exceeded 840,000, about 80,000 more than the previous year, and staff grew 1.7%. In the Semanario Judicial de la Federación (the official gazette of federal case law), the four entries dealing with artificial intelligence come from a single body, the Segundo Tribunal Colegiado en Materia Civil del Segundo Circuito (Second Collegiate Civil Court of the Second Circuit); it has two jurisprudencias (binding precedents), mandatory since January 12, 2026, in the Second Circuit, based in the State of Mexico. The first validates AI for calculating the amount of guarantees in amparo (constitutional challenge) proceedings, since these are auxiliary tasks that are not part of the decision-making core; the second sets minimum elements for its ethical and responsible use—proportionality and harmlessness, personal data protection, transparency and explainability, human oversight and decision-making—and calls for disclosing "the methodology, the data used and the way in which the result was reached". The Semanario contains no Supreme Court criterion on the subject.
Strategic interpretation
Systemic: State courts adopt generative AI out of necessity: filings grow close to 10% a year and staff 1.7%. The framework that could govern that use comes not from the Supreme Court or a law but from a collegiate court that, ruling on a guarantee calculation, also set minimum principles of use. The tension is between the productivity the local judiciary needs and the explainability required by that precedent, binding in another circuit: disclosing methodology and data is possible when calculating a guarantee and much harder when drafting reasoning. The judiciary that adopts first wins; the party that loses without knowing what the machine did bears the risk. Scaling would require other judiciaries to replicate it with their own infrastructure and no amparo (constitutional challenge) to halt it. Consequence: It falls on the judiciaries of Querétaro; of Baja California, which per press reports wants a similar model; and of the State of Mexico, in the circuit where the precedent is binding, which per press reports is preparing a tool that will not draft rulings; and on the collegiate courts reviewing an AI-drafted ruling in amparo. What follows: that first amparo will force deciding how transparency and explainability are met when AI drafts rather than just calculates. Three to ten years out: either the Supreme Court sets a national standard, or the same case is decided under different rules by state. Worldview: That a ruling is a complete human act and that the drafting tool does not matter as long as a person signs it. What to watch: Whether the first amparo against an AI-drafted ruling appears and what the collegiate court decides; whether the Supreme Court or the Órgano de Administración Judicial (judicial administration body) issue guidelines; whether the State of Mexico launches the tool it announced; and what share of rulings with AI Querétaro reports next year (today under 0.9%). Ten years out: whether judicial AI in Mexico has one regime or thirty-two.
Poder Judicial del Estado de Querétaro (Querétaro state judiciary), bulletins of September 29, 2026 (Segundo Informe, Second Report) and April 28, 2026 (first ruling with AI). Semanario Judicial de la Federación (official gazette of federal case law), jurisprudencias (binding precedents) II.2o.C. J/1 K (12a.) and II.2o.C. J/2 K (12a.), entries 2031639 and 2031640, published on January 9, 2026, and a search for "inteligencia artificial" (artificial intelligence) in the official search engine (four entries, all from the same court). All accessed and cross-checked on October 19, 2026. That Baja California wants a similar model (El Imparcial, May 25, 2026) and that the State of Mexico is preparing a tool that will not draft rulings (DigitalMex, September 13, and La Calle Libre, September 17, 2026) is press reporting only and is not included in the description.
Chapter signal radar
Published on October 20, 2026